Caleb Carr, who chronicled the dark side of human nature as a historian and novelist, most notably in his best-selling “The Alienist,” an atmospheric tale portraying the search for a serial killer in 19th-century New York, died May 23 at his home in Cherry Plain, N.Y. He was 68.
The cause was cancer, said his brother Simon Carr.
Mr. Carr spent much of his childhood in the bohemian milieu of Beat generation writers, who were a constant presence in his family’s home in Greenwich Village. The only inspiration young Caleb took from them, however, was a determination not to follow their example.
“They were noisy, drunken people, living very alternative lifestyles,” Mr. Carr told the online magazine Salon in 1997. “I wanted nothing less than to be a fiction writer when I was a kid.”
Mr. Carr said he often endured physical and psychological torment from his father, Lucien Carr, a journalist who had introduced Jack Kerouac, Allen Ginsberg and William Burroughs to one another in the 1940s.
Advertisem*nt
“My father sat around bellowing till very late in the night about love, truth, beauty,” Mr. Carr told the New York Times in 2005. “If there were things these guys often missed it was love, truth and beauty.”
Instead, young Mr. Carr became “very misanthropic” and said he valued reason and research over raw emotion. He began to study the history of violence, terrorism and warfare, later saying, “It’s safe to assume I know something about family violence and childhood violence from firsthand experience.”
After publishing a coming-of-age novel, “Casing the Promised Land,” in 1980, Mr. Carr bounced through an eclectic period as a guitarist in a punk band, an editor of a foreign policy journal, a screenwriter and an independent historian and co-author of a study of national security.
He received modest acclaim for “The Devil Soldier,” a 1992 biography of an American mercenary in 19th-century China. His next manuscript was ostensibly a historical account of the investigation of murders of young male prostitutes in New York City in 1896.
One of the central figures in the book was Theodore Roosevelt, who was then New York’s police commissioner. Another was Laszlo Kreizler, an early forensic psychiatrist, or “alienist,” who searched for clues to piece together an “imaginary picture” of the serial killer.
When his agent said the manuscript of “The Alienist” read like a novel, Mr. Carr confessed that, in fact, it was a novel. Kreizler — something of a blend of Sigmund Freud and Sherlock Holmes — was invented out of whole cloth, as were the gruesome murders.
The novel was bolstered by Mr. Carr’s deep knowledge of the social and political history of New York, including a dangerous underworld teeming with “many desperately troubled young people who every season were spat up by the dark, miserable tenement ocean that stretched away from us to the west. Forced to use whatever means they could … to survive on their own, such children were more completely on their own than anyone unfamiliar with the New York City ghettos of 1896 could possibly imagine.”
Advertisem*nt
When it was published in 1994, “The Alienist” became an immediate bestseller. Time magazine reviewer John Skow wrote that Mr. Carr’s “ability to re-create the past is truly impressive,” with “brooding, detailed cityscapes and rich historical set pieces.”
Mr. Carr’s father even praised the book. Hollywood producer Scott Rudin paid $500,000 for the film rights, although a movie was never made, and a paperback deal totaled $1 million.
In 1997, Mr. Carr published a best-selling sequel with the same characters, “The Angel of Darkness,” about a mother who kills her own children, then begins to kill others. Beginning in 2018, TNT produced an 18-part series based on “The Alienist” and “The Angel of Darkness.”
Mr. Carr used his newfound wealth to buy a 1,400-acre estate near his family’s longtime summer home in Upstate New York on a promontory called Misery Mountain near the Massachusetts border. He lived alone in a custom-built house, with 20-inch-thick stone walls.
Advertisem*nt
“If you were to ask me to trade in this book, this whole career,” he told New York magazine in 1994, “and have my childhood be different, I probably would.”
Clashes with critics
Caleb Carr, the second of three sons, was born Aug. 2, 1955, in Manhattan. His mother, the former Francesca von Hartz, was a reporter at the United Press news service, where she met Lucien Carr.
As a student at Columbia University, the charismatic Lucien Carr was considered the catalyst of the Beat movement. He befriended Kerouac and Ginsberg and introduced them to Burroughs, a writer from Carr’s hometown of St. Louis.
In St. Louis, Lucien Carr had a Boy Scout leader, David Kammerer, who became infatuated with him. He followed the young Carr to East Coast prep schools and eventually to Columbia, sometimes sneaking into his room. During an encounter in 1944 — often described in accounts as a hom*osexual advance by Kammerer — 19-year-old Lucien Carr killed his stalker with a pocket knife.
Advertisem*nt
Carr pushed the body into the Hudson River and, with Kerouac’s help, disposed of the knife and Kammerer’s eyeglasses. The corpse was quickly found, and Carr turned himself in to police. He pleaded guilty to manslaughter and served two years in prison.
Caleb Carr did not learn of this episode in his father’s life until he was 18. “I found it shocking,” he said in 2005, “but not exactly surprising.”
His parents divorced when Caleb was 8. Kerouac then proposed to his mother, who turned him down. She later married a journalist, John Speicher, who had three daughters. The children described their blended family as the “dark Brady Bunch,” after the cheery TV sitcom.
From time to time, Caleb continued to see his father — who supplied Kerouac with the roll of teletype paper on which he wrote “On the Road,” the seminal novel of the Beat movement. Lucien Carr eventually moved to Washington, as United Press International’s chief international editor, and died in 2005.
Advertisem*nt
As a child, Caleb Carr roamed Manhattan’s movie theaters and museums. In the ninth grade, he could recite Friedrich Schiller’s “Ode to Joy” in the original German. His interest in military history and weapons was deemed alarming at his Quaker high school, and his official transcript labeled him “socially undesirable.” He attended Kenyon College in Ohio for two years before receiving a bachelor’s degree in history from New York University in 1977.
Mr. Carr published 12 books but never matched the success of “The Alienist” and “The Angel of Darkness.” He taught military history at Bard College in Annandale-on-Hudson, N.Y., and occasionally spoke at writing seminars.
In 2002, in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, he published “The Lessons of Terror,” in which he argued that waging war on civilian populations has never succeeded throughout history. The book, in which Mr. Carr called for military attacks on countries harboring terrorists, was praised in some quarters, condemned in others.
Advertisem*nt
He fired back at some of his critics online, including Laura Miller of Salon and Michiko Kakutani of the New York Times, who suggested that Mr. Carr should stick to writing historical thrillers. He asked how the critics thought they were “as qualified to review books” on military history “as they are to chatter about bad women’s fiction.”
Mr. Carr published three later novels, including “The Italian Secretary” (2005), a Sherlock Holmes tale authorized by the estate of Holmes creator Arthur Conan Doyle, and “Surrender, New York” (2016), a modern-day tale of murder set in rural New York.
Mr. Carr never married and had no children.
“I made sure the abuse was going to end with me,” he told the Lit Hub Daily website in 2016.
He lived in his mountaintop retreat with an adopted cat, who was his sole companion from 2005 to 2022 and the subject of his final book, “My Beloved Monster: Masha, the Half-Wild Rescue Cat Who Rescued Me,” published in April.
Advertisem*nt
Survivors include two brothers, Simon Carr, an artist in New York, and Ethan Carr, a historian of landscape architecture at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst; three stepsisters; and his mother, Francesca Cote.
Mr. Carr admitted that anger — at injustice, at the abuse of children, at his father — was a continuing, even motivating force in his life.
“I write out of outrage,” he told People magazine in 1994. “I’m afraid of what happens the day I wake up and find I’m no longer angry about anything.”
